home logo Similartool.AI
Homeright arrowAI Newsright arrowasking-chatgpt-tough-medical-questions

Asking ChatGPT Tough Medical Questions

By Doctor Mike     Updated Mar 4, 2024

Ever wondered how well artificial intelligence can handle the tricky world of medical queries? I put ChatGPT, a language-based AI, to the test with a barrage of medical head-scratchers—a true baptism by fire.

1. CPR Recommendations

When asked about what to do if someone isn't breathing, ChatGPT displayed impressive knowledge, explaining the need for chest compressions and rescue breaths. However, it also wisely emphasized the importance of proper CPR training.

The response was almost on point, but lacked specifics for untrained bystanders. The best practice for those without CPR training is to focus on hands-only CPR to the beat of the 'Staying Alive' song.

Despite the AI's comprehensive answer, it also highlighted a crucial aspect—the potential harm if CPR is performed improperly—showing that AI can not only instruct but also consider safety.

2. The Safety of Tap Water

On the topic of tap water's drinkability, ChatGPT did not disappoint. It provided a well-informed explanation about the rigorous testing and standards municipal tap waters must meet.

The AI did a stellar job and didn't shy away from recommending checking with local authorities for more specifics or opting for filtered water if there are any doubts.

An interesting insight from ChatGPT highlighted that some bottled waters might actually harbor more bacteria than municipal tap waters, showing the AI's ability to debunk common misconceptions.

3. Medical Myths: Busted by AI

ChatGPT tackled the longstanding myth that cracking knuckles leads to arthritis head-on, citing research that found no strong link to support it, though frequent crackers might see some hand weakness.

With precision, ChatGPT warned those with joint issues or inflammation against excessive knuckle cracking, showcasing the AI's consideration for individual health contexts.

Nevertheless, ChatGPT's wisdom comes with a caveat—it reminded us that there are situations when you should avoid cracking your knuckles, such as prior injury, proving that AI can handle nuance.

4. AI's Approach to Ethical Dilemmas

ChatGPT showed a surprising level of sophistication when faced with the moral quagmire of the trolley problem, which became evident as it contemplated the ethics of sacrificing one life to save many.

While navigating through the dilemma, ChatGPT didn't shy away from the tough stuff: consent, autonomy, and exploring alternatives like advancing non-lethal therapies.

The AI's response exemplified that ethics in medicine is a complex tapestry, and while AI can contribute to the discourse, it also reinforces the perpetual need for human-led multidisciplinary teams.

5. AI in Diagnostics: A Helping Hand with Limits

On trickier medical scenarios, such as an asymptomatic patient with a bile duct dilatation, ChatGPT offered a conservative approach—monitoring rather than immediate intervention.

However, its generic advice revealed a diagnostic limitation since it didn't take into account patient specifics like abnormal tests or the presence of a stone.

While ChatGPT provided a starting framework, it was a clear sign that the personalized knowledge and judgment of a qualified doctor are irreplaceable, especially when dealing with the complexity of individual patient cases.

6. Doctors vs. AI: A Future Perspective

ChatGPT candidly assessed its potential to replace doctors and concluded that AI alone can't take over due to the intricate blend of knowledge, experience, and judgment needed in medicine.

The AI pointed out the critical components of care such as trust, emotional support, and the human connection—one-on-one interactions that machines are far from replicating.

Endorsing the notion that the art of medicine requires a human heart, ChatGPT gracefully bowed to the profound depth of human-led healthcare, securing the value of professional medical practitioners.

7. Community Feedback: Real People, Real Reactions

Internet commenters had their say, from cracking a chuckle over knuckle-cracking to questioning if the ‘good doctor’ might refer to a favored medical drama, showcasing the human side and humor in discussing AI's healthcare role.

Listeners marveled at ChatGPT's finesse yet recognized that some queries might just be a Google search away, emphasizing that while AI can inform, it doesn't always enlighten.

Snippets of wisdom highlighted the shortcomings of AI, such as ChatGPT's grasp of mathematics and the need for a filter when chugging down tap water—reminding us that perfection in AI, much like in humans, remains elusive.

8. ChatGPT: The Cyber Consultant in Healthcare

One commenter played an AI guessing game, leading ChatGPT to name-drop Doctor Mike as a leading YouTube physician, showing the AI’s ability to pull from trending information online.

The debate on daily showering and diet soda brought to light ChatGPT's role in swaying public opinions—sometimes in direct confrontation with popular beliefs.

Reactions spanned from amused encounters with ‘woke’ AI to the consideration of ethical quandaries, such as sustainably harvesting a miracle cure without dire measures—all reflecting on how AI discussions stir the pot of modern medical discourse.


This article explores the capabilities of ChatGPT in answering complex medical questions, ranging from emergency procedures to everyday health concerns. With NordVPN sponsoring the deep dive, we discover the strengths and limitations of AI in the medical field, touching on diagnostics, ethics, and personalized advice. Despite a few hiccups, ChatGPT impressively showcases knowledge, but also reveals that it's no substitute for the human touch in healthcare.